Friday, July 22, 2011

Out of Body Brain Glitch

I might take some of this seriously if I were not also aware of a body of evidence describing self directed OBEs that pretty well confirms a movement in real observational ability.  This work confirms specific parts of the brain’s engagement but stops there.

The type of data collection is also highly suspect in that we are using questionnaires that surely encourage students particularly to make it up as they went.  In fact we have shown that if you ask a group of people if they have had an OBE, that one in ten will claim.  If this were then checked against an age distribution the story would surely fall apart.  There does come a point when the testees call the test a joke and respond accordingly.

We do learn that the brain must actively maintain a body’s sense of self.  This is unexpected and quite like specific computer functions that must use brute force because of architecture.  Thus an illness would plausibly throw that processing function off.

Out-of-Body Hallucinations Linked to Brain Glitch

Jennifer Welsh, LiveScience Staff Writer

Date: 12 July 2011 Time: 02:09 PM ET

About 10 percent of the general population has had an out-of-body experience at some point in their lives.

CREDIT: © Mangojuicy | 

Out-of-body hallucinations can be freaky, and are often associated with mental or physical illness. New research has linked these experiences to instabilities in a part of the brain called the temporal lobe, and to errors in the body's sense of itself — even in healthy individuals.

"Seems to be that all of us can be placed somewhere along a sliding scale, based on how unstable or erratic our temporal lobe is, and some people are more prone to these experiences," said study researcher Jason Braithwaite of the University of Birmingham.

The temporal lobe interprets the sensory and other information coming in from the body and places it on a body map, giving us our sense of being inside our body, of looking out from our eyes. If this interpretation goes wrong, a hallucination can occur in which a person sees themselves from outside of their body, also called an out-of-body experience (OBE).

Experiencing the body

Out-of-body experiences are traditionally thought of as occurring during a near-death experience, but these aren't the only situations in which OBEs occur. They often occur during relaxed and wakeful states, or during migraines or temporal lobe seizures. About 10 percent of people in the general population have experienced an OBE. In college undergraduates, this number is double (researchers don't know why), usually falling somewhere between 20 and 25 percent.

In the researchers' sample of 63 undergraduates, 17 individuals (26 percent) reported having experienced an OBE. The volunteers filled out a questionnaire to assess their mental state. Those who had reported having an OBE showed differences on only two parts of the questionnaire: those that indicate instabilities in the brain's temporal lobe and errors in the body's sense of itself.

To measure a participant's temporal lobe stability, the surveys included questions such as: "Do you ever sense the presence of another being, despite being unable to see any evidence?” An example question from the body-distortion measures: "Do you ever have the sensation that your body, or part of it, is changing or has changed shape?"

Participants also completed a computer-based task where they were asked to imagine being in the place of a figure on the screen and to identify parts of the body (like "Which hand is the figure's glove on?"). People who had experienced OBEs were slower in their responses and more prone to make errors.

Distorted data

The distortion in our sense of bodily self could be caused by either conflicting information coming in from the body, or from disruptions of communication in the temporal lobe, which processes this information into a body map, Braithwaite told LiveScience.

"Your sense of self, of where you are in space, is not automatic, your brain needs to work it out all the time," Braithwaite said. "It's constantly sampling that information and constantly making that interpretation of where you are in space, and sometimes that interpretation goes wrong."

When this interpretation goes wrong, it could be the cause of an out-of-body experience.
The study was published in the July 2011 issue of the journal Cortex.

1 comment:

minivanjack said...

So, these "scientists" make the wild leap that OBE's are "hallucinations"! Nevermind that people can remember visual details not visible from their body positions, nevermind that the "scientists" deny that anything but the eyes can record visual information, nevermind that there is no science whatsoever to determine the difference between a "hallucination" (an image manufactured by neural malfunction) and a visual memory of an actual occurrence, Just go ahead and call something a "hallucination" anytime you like without any scientific basis whatsoever and the readers will remember to set aside 30 or 40 IQ points and go right along with that premise.