Lebanon's Failing Fishery

You see a story like this and you wonder what they are thinking. Right now these fools are fishing themselves out of business any way they can. In Newfoundland, government at least attempted to control the disaster. Here government has let them destroy their livelihoods as fast as possible.

As I have posted, modern technology allows the prospect of tenure been established. This looks like a decade moratorium would fully restore the fishery to historic levels. They need to form a fisherman’s union that asserts control over the resource and the right to fish. Then they need to let the stock rest and that process needs to be funded by alternative work. I think everybody in Newfoundland is working in the Alberta oil sands.

It is all small enough and with enough common interest that it should be possible here without a lot of government input.

And quite honestly, the government should take the position that fishermen were able to pay certain taxes twenty years ago and this must be maintained. If they cannot pay those taxes now then they should be forced out. This stops the present nonsense in which men head out for nickels.

It did not happen that way in Newfoundland, but the result was the same. Once the fishery was shut down, the fishermen began to look at alternatives and found them.

In Lebanon, with the fishery shut down and a tenure system put in place, the industry will recover overnight. I am also pleased to see that the value of refuges is fully recognized now.

Lebanon's struggling fishermen angling for a catch

by Staff Writers
Tyre, Lebanon (AFP) July 2, 2009

Mustapha Shaalan yearns for the days when he would go out to sea and haul in 40 kilograms (88 pounds) of fish in the blink of an eye.

Nowadays, like most fishermen in this southern Lebanese coastal town and elsewhere in the country, he says he is lucky if he reels in one or two kilos on a good day.

Over-fishing, pollution and dynamite fishing have all but wiped out marine life in the Mediterranean waters off the 220-kilometer-long (136-mile-long) Lebanese coast, leaving many of the country's estimated 8,000 fishermen destitute.

"The sea back in the 1960s, 70s and 80s was thick with fish and we were the envy of the town," 68-year-old Shaalan wistfully recalls, sitting on the quay of the picturesque port of Tyre.

"Our reputation extended worldwide," brags the father of seven who began fishing at age 10 and has a deeply creased, suntanned face from years spent at sea. "My pockets were always full and I traveled a lot.

"Now, look at us."

Some 2,000 families live from fishing in Tyre, a city of 100,000 located near the border with Israel, says Khalil Taha, head of the local fishermen's syndicate.

In the city's heyday, a fisherman would easily earn 500 dollars a week, but that figure is now closer to 200 dollars for an entire month, well below the minimum wage of 333 dollars, Taha said.

"The fishermen of Tyre used to do so well that when they would be offered jobs elsewhere they would turn them down," he said. "My father used to earn enough from the trade that he was able to put me and my nine brothers and sisters through private school.

"We used to go and buy our clothes at 'Nouveautes Khater', an upscale department store," added Taha, 49, who has two children and is expecting a third. "Now even the cheapest place is expensive for us."

Taha partly blames the fishermen themselves for their plight but also consecutive governments, which he said have done nothing to protect the fishing industry or help develop it.

Compounding the problem is the constant political turmoil that has rocked Lebanon for years. There was the 1975-1990 civil war, there were Israeli troops in southern Lebanon -- including in Tyre -- between 1982 and 2000 and, most recently, was the devastating 2006 war between Hezbollah and the Jewish state.

"We have been sounding the alarm for more than 10 years about our disastrous situation but no one is listening and I don't think anyone ever will," Taha laments.

Experts say many species, including red mullet, grouper and small barracudas are facing extinction in Lebanon's waters, primarily because of bad fishing practices over the years.

"We are destroying our sea, completely and totally," said Imad Saoud, an aquatic scientist at American University of Beirut. "And the problem is that the people who benefit the most from the sea -- the fishermen -- are the people destroying it the most."

He said the illegal and destructive practice of dynamite or blast fishing, spear fishing and compressor fishing, has irreversibly damaged the marine ecosystem off the coast of Lebanon.

Compressors blow air into crevices or holes at the sea bottom, frightening fish out of their hiding places.

Sewage is also dumped at sea along with heavy metals from factories, including copper, zinc and vanadium -- a metallic chemical.

In addition, greedy developers have been invading the coastline and paying no heed to the environmental impact.

"The state of the Mediterranean in Lebanon is disastrous at all levels and what is coming is even more disastrous," warned Michel Bariche, a marine biologist at American University of Beirut.

"As far as the government is concerned, even if there is a will to do something, they lack the proper know-how," he added. "Even if we scientists draw up solutions, there is no chance they will be implemented."

Bariche said he has been working directly with fishermen to convince them to create marine reserves or protected areas or risk losing their livelihood.

"We need to convince them that these reserves are for their own good, otherwise there will soon be nothing left to fish," he said.

Most of the fish caught in Lebanon comes from Israel and Egypt as drifting larvae, since the currents flow north. Lebanon also imports seafood from Turkey, Egypt and countries in the Gulf region.

Ironically, Taha said, when Israel had its troops stationed in southern Lebanon, there were more fish to catch as fishermen were not allowed to go out to sea at night.

"After the Israelis withdrew, the fishermen went out day and night, leaving no room for the fish to breath," he said. "A fish can't lift its head out of the water here without having 20 fishermen go after it."

Dahej el-Mokdad, head of the department of fisheries and wildlife at the ministry of agriculture, acknowledged that new ground rules are needed on how fishing is conducted in Lebanon but said lack of funds and political bickering has hampered progress.

"We don't have the means to do our job," he said. "We don't even have patrol boats ... and no one considers our sea as a national treasure."

Mokdad said he had submitted a proposal three years ago calling for a new strategy for the fishing industry but it had fallen on deaf ears.

"The fishermen are aware of the gravity of the situation but when they tell you that they have to work to bring in three or six dollars a day to buy bread for their families, what can you do?

"They either starve or go on using illegal practices to fish."