I also notice
that place names appear surprisingly resilient also so long as the local
population remains largely intact. Note invasion
normally meant that women were automatically absorbed. Our own history is very much the exception because
of the huge difference in practical culture.
There still may
be actual obscure remnants out there and I would look closely at the Lapps and
even Eskimo and possibly Cree for indications.
It is not likely but we need an open mind here.
There was an Ice
Age Language, good enough to easily span Asia and it lasted for thousands of
years. It makes xense to check refugia
for survivals and to do creative guessing.
15,000-year-old
'fossil' words reveal ancestral Ice Age language
By Amina Khan
May 7, 2013, 2:09 p.m.
Would Ice Age man understand us? It may depend on
the words we choose. Digging through languages in Eurasia for "fossil"
words that have escaped erosion over time, researchers say they have identified
an ancestral language that existed as far as 15,000 years ago.
This ancient language, described in Proceedings of
the National Academy of Sciences, may have given rise to several different
language groups — including Indo-European, which boasts roughly 3 billion
speakers and contains such far-flung languages as Spanish and Hindi.
The researchers first had to find cognates across
the languages – words that come from a common original source and maintain the
same meaning and similar sound, or have undergone predictable changes.
Consider the word "fart." Fart, while it did not appear to pass muster
in this paper, comes from a highly respectable linguistic lineage — it crops up
as furzen in German, frata in Old Icelandic, perdet’ in
Russian and pardate in ancient Sanskrit. Overall, speakers of these
languages can’t understand one another — and yet, the word "fart"
remains in remarkably good shape (if you take into account that Ps frequently
turn to Fs in certain language groups).
But reconstructing words for long-dead languages is
tricky business. Most words evolve too rapidly, and have a 50-50 chance of
being replaced by a noncognate every 2,000 to 4,000 years.
Luckily, some words — like numbers, pronouns and
special adverbs that see frequent use — seem to have much longer half-lives of
every 10,000 to 20,000 years.
They discovered a number of words —
"this," "I," "give," "mother,"
"hand," "black," "ashes," "old,"
"man," "fire" — that cropped up in similar form across at
least four of the seven language families studied across Eurasia. They traced
them back to 15,000 years — right around the time the glaciers would have been
melting, allowing humans greater ability to spread out over the globe and for
languages to start to diverge.
So if you ever have the unusual opportunity to say
this to someone from the Ice Age — "Black ashes? Who is this old man?
Mother, I hear fire!" — there’s a fair chance they’d get the gist of
things.
"Our results suggest a remarkable fidelity in
the transmission of some words and give theoretical justification to the search
for features of language that might be preserved across wide spans of time and
geography," the authors write.
No comments:
Post a Comment