The enigma of Enceladus

This object is locked in the Saturn gravity well which makes actual extraction likely too difficult.  It does confirm the existence of such objects and we can anticipate finding additional ones out in the kuiper belt as well.

The reason i bring that up is that slamming this object into Venus is a pretty good start on Terraforming the Planet.  There may well be enough water to completely do the job.  That may well be humanities task after we properly Terraform Terra it self.  Here we have barely begun.  As i have posted, that task will ultimately demand a human population in excess of one hundred billion and at least a thousand years.

The good news is that life extension is going to allow many of us all to contribute fully to the effort with the active assistence of robots.

The enigma of Enceladus

This tiny saturnian moon may be, pound for pound, the most valuable piece of real estate in the solar system.

By Morgan L. Cable, Linda Spilker | Published: Tuesday, August 6, 2019

https://astronomy.com/magazine/2019/08/the-enigma-of-enceladus?u

Researchers created this enhanced view of Enceladus’ south polar region by combining Cassini images taken through infrared, green, and ultraviolet filters. The tiger stripe fractures, the source of the plumes venting gas and dust into space, are prominently visible at center.

NASA/JPL-Caltech/SSI/Lunar and Planetary Institute/Paul Schenk (LPI, Houston)

“In the old time Pallas [Athena] heaved on high Sicily, and on huge Enceladus dashed down the isle, which burns with the burning yet of that immortal giant, as he breathes fire underground.”

— Quintus Smyrnaeus, The Fall of Troy

Enceladus, named after one of the Giants in Greek mythology, has an icy surface that reflects 81 percent of the light falling on it.

Cassini Imaging Team/JPL/ESA/NASA

Saturn’s sixth-largest moon, Enceladus has a diameter of only 310 miles (500 kilometers), and a mass less than 1/50,000 that of Earth. When it comes to places to look for life, however, Enceladus is at the top of the list, and it’s right in our cosmic backyard.

A bit ignored at first

English astronomer William Herschel discovered Enceladus in 1789, but it remained an enigma until the Cassini mission began orbiting Saturn in 2004. Prior to Cassini, Enceladus was a bit ignored. We didn’t know liquid water could exist that far out in the solar system, so why would anyone be that interested in another boring, dead ball of ice?

That all changed one year later, when Cassini’s magnetometer (think: fancy compass) detected something strange in Saturn’s magnetic field near Enceladus. This suggested the moon was active. Subsequent passes by Enceladus revealed four massive fissures — dubbed “tiger stripes” — in a hot spot centered on the south pole. And emanating from those cracks was a massive plume of water vapor and ice grains. Enceladus lost its label of being a dead relic of a bygone era and leaped to center stage as a dynamic world with a subsurface ocean.

But was it really an underground ocean, or more of a local southern sea? Thankfully, Cassini could answer this question, too. By verifying excess wobble over Enceladus’ orbital period, the imaging cameras confirmed that the icy crust is not connected to the world’s rocky core. This could only be possible if the crust is floating on a global, subsurface, liquid-water ocean.

Plumes spray water ice and vapor from many locations along the so-called “tiger stripes” crossing Enceladus’ south polar terrain. The four prominent fractures are about 84 miles (135 kilometers) long. This two-image mosaic of the moon shows the curvilinear arrangement of geysers, erupting from the fractures.

NASA/JPL/Space Science Institute

And Cassini didn’t stop there. Mass spectrometers aboard the spacecraft analyzed the gas and grains during multiple flythroughs of the plume. These instruments, the Ion and Neutral Mass Spectrometer (INMS) and Cosmic Dust Analyzer (CDA), found the plume contains mostly water, but also salts, ammonia, carbon dioxide, and small and large organic molecules. These findings help us paint a picture of the world underneath the ice: a possibly habitable ocean that’s slightly alkaline, with access to chemical energy in the water and geothermal energy at the rocky seafloor.

Possible energy sources

One of the greatest legacies of the Cassini mission is that it established Enceladus as possessing all three ingredients for life as we know it: water, chemistry, and energy. Water in the ocean — check. Chemistry in the simple and complex organics detected in the plume — check. These could be utilized to form the molecular machinery of life.

Energy takes a bit more explaining.

It is likely that hydrothermal vents are present at the seafloor of Enceladus. We know this because of three lines of evidence. First, INMS detected methane in the plume, at higher concentrations than would exist if sourced from clathrates (water-ice cages at high pressure with methane trapped inside) or other reservoirs in the ice. Methane is a key product of hydrothermal systems.

Second, CDA discovered silica nanograins of a particular size and oxidation state traced to the ocean. These only could have formed where liquid water is touching rock at temperatures of at least 194 degrees Fahrenheit (90 degrees Celsius), in the range of hydrothermal vents like “white smokers” here on Earth.

And third, the recent confirmation of molecular hydrogen in the plume by the INMS team strongly suggests interaction of liquid water with a rocky core.

And third, the recent confirmation of molecular hydrogen in the plume by the INMS team strongly suggests interaction of liquid water with a rocky core.

On Earth, hydrothermal vents at the base of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge host teeming ecosystems, living as far removed as one can imagine from photosynthesis. These habitats survive off of geothermal and chemical energy. A similar community might exist near a hydrothermal vent at the seafloor of Enceladus.

So, we have water, chemistry, and energy. Let’s say they have mixed together long enough for life to form. (Your guess is as good as anybody’s here — estimates range from 100,000 to 25 million years.) How might we detect it?

Assuming an energy-limited scenario (a good analog is Lake Vostok, a body of water in Antarctica that’s been covered with ice for the last 35 million years), we are probably looking at cell densities in the range of 100–1,000 cells per milliliter of ocean water. For reference, Earth’s oceans have about 1 million cells or more per milliliter.

We assume this life would use readily available building blocks — such as amino acids, which are abundant in carbonaceous chondrites and likely present all over the saturnian system — in numbers on par with Earth-based life.

This assumption is reasonable because life needs chemical complexity to carry out the reactions that keep cells functional. Then we are looking at concentrations of biomarkers on the order of less than 1 part per billion. That’s tough for current instruments to achieve, without some kind of concentration step.

Does this mean we have to wait for more advanced instruments before we search for life? Nope.

Organic enrichment in the plume

Of all the ice grains detected by the CDA instrument, a fraction had a high concentration of organic molecules, something the CDA team calls high mass organic cations (HMOC). While the instrument couldn’t specifically identify the structures of the HMOCs, a thorough analysis led to some educated guesses, such as aromatics (carbon-containing ringed structures) and oxygen- and nitrogen-bearing species. Within Enceladus’ ocean, there may be a complex organic soup of molecules.

the best theory for how these organic-rich ice grains might form is due to something called “bubbles bursting.” The grains were not only organic-rich, but also salt-poor, suggesting they came from an organic layer at the ice-ocean interface.

On Earth we have something similar floating at the surface of our ocean. It’s a film called an “organic microlayer,” as it’s not very thick and is typically made up of organics from biological activity (i.e., bits of cells) and from other sources, too.

The organic molecules like to hang out together and aren’t huge fans of salts or water, so they push these things out of the microlayer. Then, wave activity causes bubbles in this microlayer to burst, generating aerosols that are organic-rich and salt-poor.

A similar process may be happening on Enceladus. Organic molecules in the ocean may be concentrated at the ocean-ice boundary, and, just like on Earth, may force out the water and salts from this film. As the liquid surface at the base of the plume boils into vacuum, bubbles might burst and disperse the organic film, producing some grains that have a lot of organics inside, and little salt.

The result of all of this? Enceladus may be helping to concentrate the very things astrobiologists want to study the most: organic molecules.

aerosols on Earth boast organic molecules enriched hundreds to thousands of times over typical ocean concentrations. If we collect samples by flying through the plume or by landing on the surface, we may have a greater chance of detecting evidence of life on Enceladus, if it exists.

Cassini was a cooperative project of NASA, the European Space Agency, and the Italian Space Agency. The spacecraft spent more than 13 years studying Saturn, its rings, and its moons. It captured some 450,000 images and returned 635 gigabytes of science data.

NASA/JPL-Caltech

Future mission concepts

Enceladus has captivated us and given us more than enough reasons to go back. Many possible missions would do the job, and a few have been proposed in the post-Cassini era, although not yet selected by NASA to proceed.

Some would do as Cassini did — fly through the plume and analyze the gas and grains — but with upgraded instruments capable of much more sensitive and effective tests for life. Others would land on Enceladus’ south polar terrain, sampling fresh snow deposited onto the surface from the plume.

Even more ambitious concepts include a sample return mission (although with a round-trip time of 14 years, we would have to wait awhile to get that sample) or various climbing or melting robots to descend the 1.2 to 6.2 miles (2 to 10 km) through the ice shell and reach the ocean itself.

Whatever we send, the next mission to Enceladus — if indeed astrobiology is its main objective — will need a well-designed suite of instruments capable of searching for multiple, independent lines of evidence for life. Our understanding of life’s characteristics has advanced greatly since the Viking era, the last time NASA openly stated the search for life as the primary goal.

Back when the two Viking landers touched down on Mars in 1976, for example, we knew only two of the three branches of life. (Archaea, the third and most primitive branch of the tree of life, was discovered in 1977.) The Viking landers had three biological experiments designed to search for life in the martian regolith. One test result was positive, one was negative, and one was ambiguous. Since then, we have learned a great deal about how to design experiments such that an ambiguous result is much less likely.

We are also getting better at searching for biosignatures that are as agnostic to Earth life as possible. For example, a future mission to Enceladus might not target DNA, which is Earth-life-specific, but it might look for a molecule that could serve the same function for alien life: a large molecule with repeating subunits (akin to an alphabet) capable of storing information, such as the blueprints to build an alien cell. If such a molecule is detected, along with positive identification of multiple other biosignatures, a strong case could be made for the first detection in human history of life on another world.

Active, accessible, and relevant

Enceladus is not the only place that could host life. Europa has an even larger liquid water reservoir, and Titan’s ocean may entertain an unimaginably rich organic chemistry.

But Enceladus is the one place where researchers know for certain that they can access material from the ocean without the need to dig or drill (or even land). We can use technology available right now to test the hypothesis of whether life may be present somewhere else in the solar system.

Enceladus may be a tiny moon, but good things often come in small packages. The time is now to answer the key question that has driven us since we first looked up: Are we alone?