The huge problem with obesity is that working with it demands research on the part of the victim because that person will have to manage the problem and it will be an important part of their life.
This article is an excellent start. My own approach ultimately evolved to learning how to fast as a task by itself and then retraining myself to use intermittent fasting as the tool of choice. It cannot be done passively.
You are not healing something, you are learning what works and then applying it.
I lost 13 stone – now I know the truth about obesity
For years, I swallowed all the theories about fat, believing I could be obese and fit. Here are five dangerous myths, debunked
As
far back as I can remember, I was overweight. My parents were morbidly
obese, just like three of my grandparents (my maternal grandmother was
“only” obese – in other words, just fat). In my teenage years, I tried
every diet going, and would sometimes lose weight, only to put it all on
again. Eventually I concluded that so-called “normal” weight just
wasn’t realistic for me. It would mean a life of permanent hunger.
I also decided such a life wasn’t necessary: excess weight was
demonised without reason. I might be fat, but I didn’t smoke, drink,
consume fast food or red meat. And I was physically fit. I decided to
set other priorities in my life; I trained as a psychotherapist, got
married and started renovating an old house.
At the age of 30, I tipped the scales at 150kg (23st 8lb). If asked, I
told people I was comfortable with my weight and that my only wish, if
anything, was to be a bit fitter. But at that same time, I was secretly
visiting an obesity clinic as an outpatient and thinking about a
stomach-stapling operation. I eventually decided not to have the
operation, and buried myself even deeper in studies that showed that
being overweight was not really harmful.
My doctor never mentioned my weight. Every time I went, my blood pressure was enormously high, but I dismissed it as “white coat hypertension”.
I managed to ignore the fact that I was suffering frequent back pain
and that I was having trouble sleeping, in part because of my heavy
snoring.
This went on until, one day, I slipped while doing housework
and injured my knee. I know now that I tore my cruciate ligament; but at
the time my doctor said it was probably nothing to worry about and
prescribed me ibuprofen. Then I had another accident while renovating
our house. I walked with a limp for months, until it happened again.
After more than a year of pain and restricted mobility, I had a
breakdown. I realised that, over the previous few years, my health had
decreased while my weight had increased. And I knew that if I kept going
this way, within a few years I would be unable to walk – while still in
my early 30s. Something had to change.
For the first time, I consciously started thinking about my eating
behaviour and began reading up on genetics, metabolism, diets and
obesity. Although I had read around the topic for a while, I had done so
selectively. Now, I began to explore the 95% of the research to which I
had turned a blind eye. I came across the term “fatlogic” on Reddit
and it immediately resonated with me. The term doesn’t mean “fat
people’s logic”, but refers to the complex grab bag of supposedly
medical facts, well-meaning advice, homegrown ideas and fantasies that
make losing weight not only difficult, but impossible.
I
don’t consider myself stupid or naive. I have always been the kind of
person who questions things; I have a doctorate, and an interest in
science. But still I believed in so much fat logic, probably because I
was always surrounded by it. I was told from an early age that our
family had “fat genes” and that my metabolism was “broken” – which
appeared to be corroborated by my own experiences.
Tearing down the fallacies I had believed for my whole life was a
long and sometimes painful process. But in the following year, I began
to put it to practical use. I restricted my calorie intake. I moved
more. Within a year, I was in the normal weight range for my 175cm (5ft
9in) height; and a few months later I weighed 63kg (9st 13lb) – the
least I had weighed since the age of 12 or 13.
Fat logic is not just a problem for fat people; I have never met a
person who was completely free of it. Here are a handful of the most
persistent myths, debunked.
Myth 1: ‘I eat only 1,000 kcal a day, but I don’t lose weight’
There’s one thing we can all agree on: everybody needs energy. A
widespread fallacy is that there is a huge range of difference in
people’s metabolic rates. The amount of energy we need is influenced by
various factors, but the main ones are body mass, and what that mass is
made up of. A person’s energy consumption can actually be calculated
relatively precisely using certain formulae. The only information you
need is height, weight, sex and approximate daily activity levels. You
can find plenty of online calculators; just search “basal metabolic rate
calculator” (this is the number of calories you would require if you
were resting all day).
There’s a high probability that your BMR will lie somewhere between
1,400 and 2,000 kcal a day – unless you happen to fall into one of the
two extremes of very high or very low body mass. The bottom line is that
most people use far more than 1,500 kcal a day, but even people with
extremely low consumption still need significantly more energy than
1,000 kcal. Which means it’s practically impossible not to lose weight
on a daily calorie intake of 1,000 kcal.
So the question is, are you eating as little as you think you are?
Despite the common cliche of the fast food-guzzling, fat person, my
favourite meal used to be a large mixed salad with salmon. I ate it
regularly, and in my mental calorie journal I would estimate it
contained about 500 kcal. When, after many years, I finally weighed out
all the ingredients and calculated the actual number of calories they
contained, I discovered that the dressing alone, with three tablespoons
of olive oil, contained about 300 kcal.
The
number of calories in the salad itself – tomato, cucumber, red pepper
and lettuce – was within reason. Mozzarella, though, added considerably
more to the total, and the fact that the salmon was fried meant the
final tally for this meal was 1,500 kcal – three times the amount I had
estimated, and equivalent to the entire daily energy requirements for a
small, slim woman.
People can hugely misjudge their calorie intake, and overweight
people have a strong tendency to underestimate the calorie content of
their food. A study carried out in 1992
investigated people described as “diet-resistant”. These people claimed
not to be able to lose weight, despite restricting their calorie intake
to fewer than 1,200 kcal a day. But it turned out that, in their
nutrition journals, they underestimated their average calorie intake by
47% and overestimated their physical activity by 51%.
The hard truth is that anyone who believes they “don’t actually eat
that much” and then still inexplicably puts on weight doesn’t have a
problem with their metabolism, but with their perception of their own
eating habits.
Myth 2: ‘Being overweight isn’t that bad for you’
This is the fat logic argument I encounter most often, and which I
believed myself for many years. It is also the one I kick myself about
the most, in retrospect. I always claimed to have made a rational
decision about my weight, but I was labouring under two
misapprehensions: that it is extremely difficult to achieve and maintain
normal weight; and that it doesn’t have all that many advantages
anyway. Now, I argue the opposite whenever I can.
I respect anyone’s decision to set other priorities and happily accept being overweight or obese. Just because you can change a situation, it doesn’t mean you must. That said, it’s important for that decision to be an informed one.
This is not about whether your bum looks better as a size 36 or a
size 42. Rather, it’s about what goes on inside our bodies, and about
how being overweight directly affects our quality of life. Obesity
is a bit like smoking: the tumours don’t start growing right after the
first cigarette. For someone who is naturally prone to lung problems, it
might take five years. Another person’s lungs might be able to take 50
years of constant damage. But just because the damage isn’t visible, it
doesn’t mean it isn’t there.
Analysis from 2013
investigated the long-term consequences of obesity with the specific
aim of examining so-called “healthily obese” people. A comparison
between healthy people of normal weight and healthy but obese subjects
showed the latter group had a significantly higher risk of dying or
developing cardiovascular disease. The scientists who carried out the
study therefore came to the conclusion that the belief you can be “fat
but fit” is just a myth.
A 2015 study
confirmed those results. It followed supposedly healthily obese
subjects over 20 years and found that more than half became unhealthily
obese during that time. Their risk of becoming ill was eight times
higher than that of the healthy group with normal weight. The risks
include, but are not limited to: diabetes, cardiovascular disease,
cancer, sleep apnoea, arthritis/joint problems, fertility problems,
asthma, back pain, incontinence, gout and stroke.
Myth 3: ‘Being overweight doesn’t impede me’
For a long time, I convinced myself that being overweight didn’t
impact particularly negatively on my life. I’d suppress the panting as I
climbed the stairs, so I could tell myself I had no problem walking up
three floors. Once at the top, I would sometimes pretend to cough or
laugh to hide the fact that I was out of breath.
Our society makes it very easy for us to delude ourselves. People who
exercise regularly are seen as “fitness freaks”, “sports fanatics” or
similar, while “normal” people are the ones who lead physically inactive
lives. Now that I can compare the abilities of my well-trained body
(and I’m absolutely not athletic or super-fit) with my abilities before,
I’ve come to realise how far below optimum my fitness level really was.
I’m not saying there aren’t any overweight people who do a lot of
exercise. But I can imagine lots of people fall prey to a similar kind
of distorted thinking as I did: I used to consider even relatively
normal things to be great sporting achievements.
The same applies to the achievement a US leader of the fat-acceptance movement, Ragen Chastain,
claims makes her an “elite athlete” – with a morbidly obese BMI. In
2013, she ran a marathon and published an article about it with the
title My Big Fat Finished Marathon. She wrote about how, after five months of training, she covered just over 40km in 12 hours and 20 minutes.
It is an achievement for a severely obese person to walk the entire
length of a marathon in one go. But Chastain’s average speed of less
than 3.5km (2.2 miles) an hour is much slower than normal walking speed.
The marathon had officially ended hours before she crossed the
finishing line – the stands removed, the organisers gone. The last
participant to complete the race, several hours before Chastain, was a
woman in her 70s.
Of course, everyone has to start from their own fitness level. When I
weighed 150kg and was more or less unable to move for six months,
average sporting achievements were as likely for me as breaking Olympic
records. In the first few months, I was proud of reaching various
milestones, such as walking for half an hour without stopping, or
spending 20 minutes on a bike for the first time in years.
It’s good to be proud of your own development and individual
progress, even when it might not objectively seem that impressive. But
declaring your own, below-average performance to be an objective record,
and therefore to claim that any improvement is unnecessary, will only
stop you – and others – from tackling the problem of excess weight.
Myth 4: ‘My family and friends don’t think I need to lose weight’
This statement is fat-logical only when referring to people who are
not underweight or for whom losing weight would mean they would become
underweight. Let me start with my own experience. When I weighed 150kg,
there was no one who seriously claimed that losing weight would not be a
good idea for me. But apart from my mother, as far as I can remember,
in all those years nobody ever asked me about my weight. My weight was
the elephant in the room, which no one mentioned – until I brought it up
myself.
I lost my first 40kg (6st) in secret, without anyone noticing. When I
reached about 105kg (16st 7lb), everyone around me suddenly noticed I’d
lost weight. At over 100kg, I was still very much within the obese
range, but others saw it quite differently. From all sides, I was asked,
surely I didn’t want to lose any more weight? I must be done with my
diet now, right? Yeah, that’s terrific losing so much weight, but you
don’t need to lose any more – surely?
A neighbour who saw me gardening worriedly asked my husband how much I
now weighed and asked him please to make sure I ate more. When I ran
into a colleague on the street, she half-jokingly asked when I was going
to be diagnosed with anorexia; another admitted he deliberately hadn’t
reacted too enthusiastically to my new size for fear I might go to “the
other extreme”.
It was ironic: when I was sick and almost bedridden at 150kg, no one
ever expressed concern or commented on my weight in any way. And then,
when I lost 40kg, was able to walk again and feeling better than I had
for years, people started to get worried about my health. It was as if
my body had suddenly become a public forum, after years of having been a
taboo subject.
Why is it so socially acceptable to criticise someone for losing
weight? Because most people don’t know what overweight looks like. In
one British study, obese people were asked to assess themselves, and
only 11% of women and 7% of men with a BMI of over 30 were aware they
were obese. In a 2015 study,
parents were asked about the weight of their children: 80% of parents
of overweight children rated them as being of normal weight.
Myth 5: ‘Obesity is largely due to your genes’
Genes create a basic situation, but they don’t oblige anyone to be
fat. Things that can genuinely be explained by genetics are appetite,
preferences for certain flavours (such as sweet or fatty) and the
natural urge to be physically active.
Several studies have shown that carriers of so-called obesity genes
consume on average 125-280 kcal a day more and have no differences in
their metabolic rates. To say that some children have a genetic
propensity towards obesity means only that they have an inherently
larger appetite than naturally slim children, who feel hungry less
often.
But the deciding factor in whether children have a tendency towards
being fat is the set of conditions created by their parents and the rest
of their environment (such as school meals), which can serve either to
encourage or discourage obesity. Living in a household where
high-calorie food is constantly available won’t necessarily make
children fat if their genetics mean they have a naturally small
appetite. Children with naturally large appetites, by contrast, will
pounce on the proffered fare.
However, studies have shown that food preferences are not an
inescapable fate. In one experiment, the brains of obese and normal
weight subjects were scanned to record their reactions to food. The
reward centres in the obese subjects’ brains showed a strong reaction to
high-fat foods (fast food, sweets). The test was repeated after the
subjects had followed a dietary plan containing healthy, low-calorie
foods for several months. The reward centres in the obese subjects’
brains reacted more strongly to these foods in the second test.
In the end, our genes just set out the path we will follow if we
don’t actively strive to change its direction (which can take great
effort). However, those efforts are only temporary: once we have become
habituated to new behaviours, we no longer have to struggle to maintain
them.
***
So how is my life now that I’m maintaining my target weight? The
actual weight loss hasn’t changed much, but the impact on my life has
been great. The fact I now take pleasure in exercise has opened up an
entire spectrum of new interests to me that would once have been out of
the question. My husband and I went on a cycling holiday. I’ve
discovered climbing as a new hobby – and pilates, too. My gym buddy and I
now meet once a week for coffee and weight training. I’ve gained so
much – and have come to see that being thin doesn’t have to mean a life
of constant deprivation.
No comments:
Post a Comment