I think that they have it right to blame humanity for killing off the cave bears but that was mostly because of their choice of den. It is simply too easy to locate the animals in the fall and to wait until they are asleep before entering the cave and killing the animal in its own trap.
It was likely just too big to use natural deadfalls as other bears do.
The easy way to kill a cave trapped bear would to fill the cave mouth with brush and set a nice large bonfire. With no escape, the bear would perish from either lack of oxygen or smoke inhalation. Certainly better than entering the cave with a spear to face a rushing bear.
In short, it was an easy winter feast for the local humans.
True Causes For Extinction Of Cave Bear Revealed
by Staff Writers
This Ursus spelaeus male skull found in Cova Eiros (Triacastela, Lugo
The cave bear started to become extinct in
"The decline in the genetic diversity of the cave bear (Ursus spelaeus) began around 50,000 years ago, much earlier than previously suggested, at a time when no major climate change was taking place, but which does coincide with the start of human expansion", Aurora Grandal-D'Anglade, co-author of the study and a researcher at the University Institute of Geology of the University of Coruna, tells SINC.
According to the research study, published in the journal Molecular Biologyand Evolution, radiocarbon dating of the fossil remains shows that the cave bear ceased to be abundant in Central Europe around 35,000 years ago.
"This can be attributed to increasing human expansion and the resulting competition between humans and bears for land and shelter", explains the scientist, who links this with the scarce fossil representation of the bear's prey in the abundant fossil record of this species.
In order to reach their conclusions, the team of scientists, led by the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology (Germany) studied mitochondrial DNA sequences from bear fossils in European deposits (Siberia, Ukraine, Central Europe and the Iberian Peninsula, specifically Galicia), and carried out a Bayesian analysis (of statistical probability).
The scientists also made comparisons with the modern brown bear (Ursus arctos) and with fossil samples of this species of bear, and managed to show why one became extinct and the other did not.
In order to demonstrate this, the study analysed 59 cave bear DNA sequences and 40 from the brown bear, from between 60,000 and 24,000 years ago for the cave bear and from 80,000 years ago up to the present day for the brown bear.
Decline of the caves, extinction of the bears
The impoverishment of ecosystems during the last glacial maximum was "the 'coup de grace' for this species, which was already in rapid decline", the author explains.
The present day brown bear did not suffer the same fate and has survived until today for one simple reason - brown bears did not depend so heavily on the cave habitat, which was becoming degraded, and this is why they did not follow the same pattern as the cave bears.
"Brown bears rely on less specific shelters for hibernation. In fact, their fossil remains are not very numerous in cave deposits", the Galician researcher says.
The definitive extinction of the cave bear "broadly" coincides with the last cooling of the climate during the Pleistocene (between 25,000 and 18,000 years ago), which may have led to a reduction in shelter and the vegetation that the animals fed on.
The cave bear inhabited Europe during the Late Pleistocene and became definitively extinct around 24,000 years ago, although it held out for a few thousand years longer in some areas, such as the north west of the Iberian Peninsula, than in other places.
This ursid was a large animal, weighing 500 kg on average, and was largely a herbivore. The bear hibernated in the depths of limestone caves, where the remains of individuals that died during hibernation slowly accumulated over time.
As science goes, this is pretty vacuous. No bear DNA would be changed by humans. If the claim is that they stole their caves, then looking in the caves to see how many had bears and how many humans' bones were found in the caves. Looking at their DNA won't prove a thing.
ReplyDeleteThe science in this is vacuous at best. I can see that perhaps *something* in the DNA might indicate that they were less able to live in colder climates, but you don't really say that. If the claim is they were kicked out of their caves by humans, that would be proved by human bones in caves, not DNA, and that isn't mentioned at all. Nothing here would qualify as scientific "proof."
ReplyDeleteThe problem is why the cave bear. Mankind is hunted by the weaker grizzlies and polar bears.
ReplyDeleteThe cave bear was too large to use alternative hibernation strategies such as crawling under dead falls and making a nest.
Also humans used caves but rarely lived there. They were natural traps as they showed the cave bear.
The simple expedient of maintaining a bonfire at the mouth of the cave will allow carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide to kill the occupant(s).